Keidan-Harrison_Logo_85-bc60ee12
(Satyam Enterprises Ltd v Burton and another)

The High Court considered whether there had been an unlawful return of capital within the meaning of Part 23 of the Companies Act 2006 (CA 2006). The alleged distribution took place at a time when the claimant, Satyam Enterprises Ltd, was called JVB Five Properties Ltd (JVB5). JVB5 claimed that in October 2012, Mr Burton, its sole director, had authorised the sale of 12 flats in Croydon (the Croydon properties) at a significant undervalue to JVB Seven Properties Ltd (JVB7) of which he was also the sole shareholder and director. The court relied on the principles in Progress Property Co Limited v Moore where Lord Walker held ‘whether or not the transaction is a distribution to shareholders does not depend exclusively on what the parties choose to call it.

The court looks at the substance rather than the outward appearance’. The court held that authorities arising out of the Insolvency Act 1986 (IA 1986) in respect of antecedent transactions under IA 1986, ss 238, 239 and 423 were not relevant to the court’s enquiry into the true purpose and substance of the transaction in question. Despite the court finding an arithmetical difference between the value of the Croydon properties and the consideration given by JVB7 it held that it was genuinely intended to be a market value transaction and not a dressed-up return of capital. The claim was dismissed. 

See our latest News

Sareesh Rawat

Commencing an Appeal Due to the Deemed Denial of a CDA Claim

May 15, 2025

Minh Nguyễn Hoàng

Regulations on Charter Capital and Financial Reporting of...

May 15, 2025

Minh Nguyễn Hoàng

Vietnam Golden Visa: Validity, Renewal, and Pathway to Pe...

May 15, 2025

Edith Nordmann

Can a bank terminate your account without reason?

May 15, 2025

Edith Nordmann

Temporary Agency Work via Platforms: Even Private Househo...

May 15, 2025

Edith Nordmann

Integrating ESG in the Blue Economy and Emerging Risks in...

May 15, 2025

Minh Nguyễn Hoàng

Legal Framework for Corporate Bond Issuance – Comprehensi...

May 15, 2025

Minh Nguyễn Hoàng

Enforcement of Security Interests: The Key to Solving Bad...

May 14, 2025

Minh Nguyễn Hoàng

Overview of the Legal Framework for Fund Management Compa...

May 13, 2025

Charles Savva

Work Remotely, Live Freely: Cyprus Reopens Digital Nomad ...

May 13, 2025